The Demise of Thomas Pengilley – Old Geelong Gaol
Mrs Pengilley, afraid for her children contacted the local police and had Thomas detained. He was sent to the Kew Lunatic Asylum. Pengilley spent time in and out of Kew over a span of a few years. His erratic and unpredictable behaviour caused problems for the hotel’s income. Often Pengilley would become unfriendly and hostile toward patrons, causing his wife to shut the doors.
On the night of his death, a warder brought him a glass of water around 6pm. The Warder noticed that Pengilley was morose and slightly unhinged. He left him be and returned at 9pm. The warder pushed the cell door open and discovered Pengilley had hung himself by tying a valise strap around his neck and attaching it to a gas bracket above the door, hanging himself.
![]() |
| Yarra Ben Asylum - Victoria |
The tragedy of the Pengilleys does not end there. Thomas's oldest son, Thomas junior was accused in 1889 of not paying maintenance of a child he had had out of wedlock. In the same year, Thomas, like his father before him, found himself admitted to Kew Lunatic Asylum.
In 1890, Thomas Jr. Was formally charged with deserting his child. The child’s mother, Phillis Labatt stated in court that Pengilley had fled to Broken Hill, she also stated that he was a frequent resident of the Yarra Bend Lunatic Asylum. Pengilley died at the age of 38 in 1899.
![]() |
| Victoria Police Gazette - May 21 1890 |
'BIRREGURRA NEWS.', Geelong Advertiser, (2 September 1889), p. 3.
'BIRREGURRA.',The Colac Herald, (11 July 1882), p. 3.
'Family Notices', The Argus, (9 October 1899), p. 1.
'Family Notices', Geelong Advertiser, (6 February 1880), p. 2.
'GEELONG.', The Age, (5 February 1880), p. 3.
'POLICE COURT.', Geelong Advertiser, (9 November 1889), p. 4.
'SUICIDE IN THE GEELONG GAOL.', The Ballarat Courier, (6 February 1880), p. 3.
'TOWN TALK.', Geelong Advertiser, (23 May 1890), p. 2.
Victoria, Australia, Police Gazettes, 1855, 1864-1924 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2016.
Original data: Victoria Police Gazette Indexes. CD-ROM. Ridgehaven, South Australia: Gould Genealogy and History, 2009.




